Alcohol and Alcoholism Advance Access published online on January 27, 2008
Alcohol and Alcoholism, doi:10.1093/alcalc/agn001
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Association Between Smoking and The Risk of Heavy Drinking Among Young Women: A Prospective Study
1 National Institute of Public Health, Department of Alcohol Research, Oester Farimagsgade 5, DK-1399 Copenhagen, Denmark
2 Department of Virus, Hormones and Cancer, Institute of Cancer Epidemiology, Danish Cancer Society/National Hospital of Denmark, Strandboulevarden 49, DK-2100 Copenhagen, Denmark
* Author to whom correspondence should be addressed at: National Institute of Public Health, Oester Farimagsgade 5, DK-1399 Copenhagen, Denmark. Tel.: +45 –39 20 77 77; Fax: +45 39 20 80 10; E-mail: MG{at}niph.dk
Received 27 July 2007; ; accepted 18 December 2007
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Aim: To address the association between smoking habits and the risk of later heavy drinking among young women. Methods: Repeated assessments of alcohol and smoking habits were obtained in 1991–93 and 1999–2000 in a Danish representative cohort in Copenhagen. A total of 6369 non- to moderate-drinking Danish women, aged 20–29 years at baseline, attended a follow-up examination and were included in the study. The risk of becoming a heavy drinker (more than 14 drinks per week) 8 years after enrolment was analyzed by means of logistic regression. Results: A total of 177 women became heavy drinkers during follow-up. Daily smoking at baseline was associated with an increased risk of becoming a heavy drinker 8 years later. Relative to nonsmokers, the adjusted odds ratios (OR) for becoming a heavy drinker associated with smoking 1–14, 15–24, or more than 24 cigarettes per day were 1.6 (95% confidence intervals (CI) 1.1–2.4), 1.7 (CI 1.1–2.6), and 2.3 (CI 0.9–5.9), respectively. Age at sexual debut modified the effect of smoking, and women with a debut before the age of 15 years had an adjusted OR of 2.9 (CI 1.1–3.9) compared to never-smokers while there seemed to be no effect among women with a sexual debut after the age of 18. In addition, relative to nondrinkers, all of the moderate (1–5 units per week), medium (6–10 units), and large (10–14 units) alcohol consumption at baseline were associated independently with becoming a heavy drinker 8 years later. Conclusions: This study suggests that smoking is an important predictor of later heavy drinking among young women and that this relatively elevated risk is most pronounced among women with an early sexual debut.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The association of tobacco and alcohol consumption has been examined in several cross sectional studies (Bien and Burge, 1990
The aim of the present study was to investigate the relation between smoking and subsequent heavy drinking among young non- and moderate-drinking women.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Study population
The study is based on a prospective cohort comprising 11,088 women. The selection was a random sample selected within age strata 20–29 years of the female population in Copenhagen, Denmark by means of the computerized Central Population Register. The participants were all born in Denmark and were invited to participate in the study by letter. Information on the participants was collected through an interview carried out by trained nurses and a self-administered dietary questionnaire, including drinking habits, which had to be returned by mail. The cohort was established by Department of Virus, Hormones and Cancer (Danish Cancer Society) from May 1991 to January 1993 and continued to 2000 with a mean follow-up time of 8.1 years (range 7.2–9.3 years). The cohort was established with the purpose of studying the natural history of papillomavirus infection and cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. The Ethical Committee of Copenhagen and Frederiksberg Municipalities approved the study. Procedures for enrolment and data collection are described in details elsewhere (Kjaer et al., 1996
A total of 16,345 women were invited, of which 11,088 (68%) were included in the first part of the study. The present study is based on all the 6747 women who returned the dietary questionnaire at the baseline and who participated in the follow-up in 2000. In order to investigate the risk of becoming heavy drinker, only those women who were non- to moderate drinkers at the baseline were included (6519). A total of 150 women had not answered the relevant questions regarding the covariates used and thus 6369 (57%) were eligible for analyses in this study.
Outcome
The participants were dichotomized into heavy drinkers and non- to moderate drinkers at the follow-up based on self-reports in a dietary questionnaire. The outcome heavy drinking was defined as an intake of more than 14 units of alcohol per week. This definition was based on the recommendations from the Danish National Board of Health (Gronbaek et al., 1997
). The alcohol consumption was calculated as the total weekly intake of beer (bottles), wine (glasses), and spirits (units). A bottle of beer contains 12 g alcohol and is similar to 1/6 bottle of wine or 1 serving of spirits (4 cl).
Exposure
Information on smoking habits was obtained from the dietary questionnaire at baseline. The participants reported if they were current smokers, never smokers, or former smokers. The definition of being a current smoker was a person who smoked one or more cigarettes per day during the month prior to the interview. The women were categorized as never smokers, former smokers, 1–14 cigarettes per day, 15–24 cigarettes per day, and more than 24 cigarettes per day.
Covariates
The following covariates, based on self-reports from the interview and the dietary questionnaire, were assumed to potentially confound the analyses: Average weekly consumption of alcohol at baseline (nondrinkers, <1 unit of alcohol/week, 1–5 units/ week, >5–10 units/week, and >10–14 units/week). The alcohol intake at baseline was included as both a continuous and categorical measure. Furthermore, age (20–21, 22–23, 23–24, 26–27, and 28–29 years old) and cohabitation (cohabitant or living alone) were included as covariates. Cohabitants referred to married women and women who lived with a partner. Living alone included divorced, widowed or not married women who were living alone. We further included education (1–10 years and >10 years), parity (0 births, 1 birth and more than 1 birth), number of spontaneous abortions (0, 1–2, and more than 2), number of induced abortions (0, 1–2, and more than 2), number of sexual partners (0, 1–5, 6–10, 10–15, and >15), history of sexually transmitted diseases (yes or no to have had at least one of the following diseases: Chlamydia, gonorrhoea, syphilis, genital warts, herpes or any other kind of sexually transmitted disease), using contraceptives at the first intercourse (yes, no), and age at first sexual intercourse (12–14 years, 15–18 years, and >18 years).
| STATISTICS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals (CI) for becoming a heavy drinker were estimated by means of logistic regression (SAS/STAT version 9.1). Age of the women and alcohol intake at baseline examination were entered into all the analyses. Selection of confounders was based on the change-in-estimate method described by Greenland and Rothman (Greenland and Rothman, 1998
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A total of 177 women became heavy drinkers during follow-up. Based on the percentwise distributions presented in Table 1 it seemed that women who smoked had a greater consumption of alcohol, a higher mean age, a greater proportion of women living alone, a greater proportion of low educated, a higher mean number of sexual partners, a higher mean number of induced abortions, a greater proportion of women with a history of sexually transmitted diseases, a greater proportion who had not used protection at first intercourse, and a lower mean age at sexual debut than never smokers. Smokers did not differ from nonsmokers with regard to mean number of births, and number of spontaneous abortions.
|
Daily smoking at baseline was associated with an increased risk of becoming a heavy drinker at follow-up, even after adjusting for alcohol consumption at baseline as a continuous measure (Table 2). Women who smoked more than 24 cigarettes per day had an adjusted odds ratio of 2.3 (CI 0.9–5.9) of becoming heavy drinkers at follow-up compared to participants who had never smoked. Women who smoked between 14 and 24 cigarettes per day had adjusted odds ratio of 1.7 (CI 1.1–2.6) and women who smoked between 1 and 14 cigarettes a day had adjusted odds ratio of 1.6 (CI 1.1–2.4) of becoming a heavy drinker at follow-up compared to women who had never smoked.
|
Alcohol consumption at baseline, but also age at first intercourse, were additionally shown to be predictors for heavy alcohol consumption at follow up. For women with a baseline alcohol consumption at 1–5 units per week, the adjusted OR for becoming a heavy drinker 8 years later was 2.2 (CI 1.0–4.7) and for women with an alcohol consumption at 10–14 units per week at baseline, the adjusted OR for becoming a heavy drinker was 27.0 (CI 12.3–59.2) compared to a weekly intake of less than 1 unit. For women with a sexual debut before the age of 15, the adjusted OR for becoming a heavy drinker was 2.1 (CI 1.1–3.9) compared to women with a sexual debut after the age of 18 years (Table 2).
A significant interaction was found between age at sexual debut and smoking status. Hence, as shown in Table 3, the risk of being a heavy drinker at follow-up was restricted to women with a lower age at first intercourse. In the group of women with a sexual debut before the age of 15 years, the odds ratio for becoming a heavy drinker was 2.2 (CI 0.9–5.4) for ex-smokers, 2.2 (CI 1.0–4.7) for current smokers smoking
14 cigarettes per day, and 2.9 (CI 1.5–5.9) for current smokers smoking more than 14 cigarettes. For the women with sexual debut after the age of 18, the corresponding odds ratios were respectively 1.0 (CI 0.3–3.2) for ex-smokers, 1.0 (CI 0.4–2.3) for current smokers (CI
14 cigarettes per day), and 0.5 (CI 0.1–1.8) for current smokers with a daily consumption of more than 14 cigarettes. These analyses were adjusted for alcohol consumption as a categorical measure (instead of a continuous measure) because of the small sizes of the strata.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The present study demonstrates that smoking among non- to moderate-drinking young women increases their risk of later becoming heavy drinkers compared to never-smoking women. The greater relative risk was more pronounced among women with an early sexual debut. In addition, the study demonstrates that light to large alcohol consumption is an important predictor of later heavy drinking among young women, when compared to abstainers.
The findings of this study are supported by a study (Jensen et al., 2003
) on the elderly Danish population with a mean age of 50 and a follow-up time between 5 and 10 years, where the authors found a prospective association between smoking and later alcohol consumption. In a study by Jackson et al. (Jackson et al., 2003
) the positive association between smoking and later alcohol consumption in a general population with mean age 44 years was only present on a short-term basis (1 year) and not on a long-term basis (16 years) (Jackson et al., 2003
) which could be due to a different population sample and different alcohol and smoking measures. The population sample Jackson et al. studied had 79% men, the outcome was defined as alcohol use disorder (pathological alcohol use), and the exposure was nicotine dependence (10 cigarettes a day for the past year).
The findings of a moderate alcohol consumption as an independent predictor of later heavy drinking is almost equivalent with the OR for smoking and later heavy drinking and is supported by a study where drinking alcohol more than once a month was shown to be associated with later heavy drinking (more than 14 units per week for women) (Andersen et al., 2003
) which indicates that even a moderate alcohol intake in early adulthood may be a beginning of a large-scale alcohol consumption in adulthood. Furthermore, a recent study found that for women the risk of developing alcoholism after 25 years increases even with low levels of alcohol consumption at baseline (Flensborg-Madsen et al., 2007
). From a health promotion point of view it is important to know if drinking behavior in young adulthood tracks into adulthood. The very high, adjusted OR for becoming a heavy drinker for women with a large alcohol consumption at baseline is interesting though not surprising since only a slight increase in alcohol consumption during the 8 years of follow-up would place these women in the heavy-drinking category. The result could also be due to an underreporting at baseline, such that some of the women who reported to consume between 10 and 14 units per week were actually heavy drinkers already at baseline and have continued to drink above the recommended 14 units per week during the 8 years of follow-up.
This study has the advantage of repeated assessments of drinking and smoking habits among the same participants and a large sample size. Since information regarding health behaviors was obtained prospectively, differential recall bias was eliminated.
One limitation of the current study is that the results could be subject to selection bias, since participants who did not participate in both examinations and did not return the dietary questionnaire in phase 1 were excluded from the analysis. Participants who did not attend follow-up were more often drinking, smoking, and low educated and this contributes to the risk of selection bias. We do not expect nonresponse to have affected the internal validity but it can reduce the generalizability of the study.
The information on smoking and alcohol consumption were self-reported measurements, therefore underreporting by the participants is not impossible. The analyses were made with different definitions of heavy drinkers, and according to this, the number of women in each category differed considerably as a high percentage of the women drank close to 14 units of alcohol per week. However, the association was present independently of which definition was used. The results would be biased if underreported alcohol consumption were associated with smoking at baseline. A false association would appear if many smoking moderate drinkers from the first examination were in fact heavy drinkers, thereby having a greater risk of also being a heavy drinker at follow-up. The reliability of self-reported alcohol intake has been investigated in a Danish cohort, showing no important differences between self-reported questionnaires and dietary interviews, but some underestimation is not impossible (Gronbaek and Heitmann, 1996
).
Underreporting of smoking could also bias the results and create a stronger relation between smoking and drinking but the authors of a previous study have validated data on self-reported smoking and found small differences based on serum cotinine (Patrick et al., 1994
). The number of cigarettes smoked per day in this study could be overestimated since the variable is a combination of two questions, regarding current smoking status and cigarettes smoked per day when the subjects were smoking the most. An overestimation could result in bias towards the null. The group of ex-smokers is likely to be nonhomogeneous, since women categorizing themselves as ex smokers could relapse into smoking during follow-up. Results from this group should be interpreted with caution and need further investigation with, for instance, information about time since quitting.
Since the association between smoking and later heavy drinking was most pronounced among women with an early sexual debut, sexual habits could have influenced the results by being a function of common third variables, risky behavior or special personality traits such as sensation-seeking regarding smoking, alcohol, and sexual behaviors. In a previous studies, sensation seeking was found to be associated with alcohol and smoking behavior (Kraft and Rise, 1994
); another study (Graves and Leigh, 1995
) concluded that sexual activity was associated with alcohol consumption and smoking. Furthermore, individuals who report symptoms of anxiety and depression are highly represented amongst those who smoke tobacco and consume alcohol at harmful levels (Alati et al., 2004
), which could have influenced the association found between smoking and later alcohol consumption.
Previous studies have found that the use of either tobacco or alcohol predicts a future dependence of the other (Jackson et al., 2003
; Simon et al., 1995
) and results from twin and family studies have pointed at a shared genetic predisposition as an biological explanation (Grucza and Bierut, 2006
; True et al., 1999
). The effect of nicotine on alcohol consumption has been documented in several animal studies showing an increased self-administered use of alcohol among rats exposed to nicotine (Rose et al., 2004
; Le et al., 2003
). A study by Ritchey et al. found that adolescents had a greater pleasure caused by a synergistic effect of the use of both substances together, which could explain the cooccurrence of the two substances (Ritchey et al., 2001a). Furthermore, smoking and alcohol consumption can be seen as complementary behaviors (Room, 2004
) and influenced by a social context since tobacco and alcohol are often used in the same situations (Johnson and Jennison, 1992
).
It cannot be clarified whether smoking influences later alcohol consumption directly or through a common third variable such as a general risk behavior. However, the prospective relationship between smoking and alcohol consumption especially among women with an early sexual debut, and between alcohol consumption and later heavy drinking, is important to recognize when identifying risk groups and designing preventive strategies. Young women with a high alcohol consumption is a particular public health concern since they might become pregnant and expose the fetus to alcohol with the attendant risk of fetal alcohol syndrome.
In conclusion, smoking was shown to increase the risk of becoming a heavy drinker 8 years later among light to moderate drinking women. This was most pronounced for women with an early sexual debut. Alcohol consumption and age at sexual debut were likewise predictors of later heavy drinking.
| FUNDING |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The Danish Ministry of Health supported this study. All authors were independent from funders.
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
Morten Grønbæk initiated this project and the analytical strategy was developed in collaboration with Susanne Krüger Kjær, Camilla Schmidt Morgen, and Kira Bang Bové. Susanne Krüger Kjær, who also contributed to the methodological discussions, supplied data. Camilla Schmidt Morgen and Kira Bang Bové drafted the manuscript. Camilla Schmidt Morgen and Katrine Strandberg Larsen were responsible for the data analysis. All authors critically revised the manuscript.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Alati R., Kinner S., Najman J. M., et al. Gender differences in the relationships between alcohol, tobacco and mental health in patients attending an emergency department. Alcohol and Alcoholism (2004) 39:463–469.
Andersen A., Due P., Holstein B. E., et al. Tracking drinking behaviour from age 15–19 years. Addiction (2003) 98:1505–1511.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Bien T. H., Burge R. Smoking and drinking: A review of the literature. International Journal of the Addictions (1990) 25:1429–1454.[Web of Science][Medline]
Castilla J., Barrio G., Belza M. J., et al. Drug and alcohol consumption and sexual risk behaviour among young adults: Results from a national survey. Drug and Alcohol Dependence (1999) 56:47–53.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Daeppen J. B., Smith T. L., Danko G. P., et al. Clinical correlates of cigarette smoking and nicotine dependence in alcohol-dependent men and women. The collaborative study group on the genetics of alcoholism. Alcohol and Alcoholism (2000) 35:171–175.
De Leon J, Rendon D. M., Baca-Garcia E., et al. Association between smoking and alcohol use in the general population: Stable and unstable odds ratios across two years in two different countries. Alcohol and Alcoholism (2007) 42:252–257.
DiFranza J. R., Guerrera M. P. Alcoholism and smoking (1990) 51:130–135.
Fleming R., Leventhal H., Glynn K., et al. The role of cigarettes in the initiation and progression of early substance use. Addictive Behaviors (1989) 14:261–272.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Flensborg-Madsen T., Knop J., Mortensen E. L., et al. Amount of alcohol consumption and risk of developing alcoholism in men and women. Alcohol and Alcohoisml (2007) 42:442–447.[CrossRef]
Graves K. L., Leigh B. C. The relationship of substance use to sexual activity among young adults in the United States. Family Planning Perspectives (1995) 27:18–22, 33.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Greenland S., Rothman K. J. Introduction to stratified analysis. In: Modern Epidemiology—Rothman K. J., Greenland S., eds. (1998) Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. 253–279.
Gronbaek M., Heitmann B. L. Validity of self-reported intakes of wine, beer and spirits in population studies. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition (1996) 50:487–490.[Web of Science][Medline]
Gronbaek M. N., Iversen L., Olsen J., et al. Sensible drinking limits. Ugeskrift for Laeger (1997) 159:5939–5945.[Medline]
Grucza R. A., Bierut L. J. Co-occurring risk factors for alcohol dependence and habitual smoking: Update on findings from the collaborative study on the genetics of Alcoholism. Alcohol Research and Health (2006) 29:172–178.[Web of Science][Medline]
Gulliver S. B., Kalman D., Rohsenow D. J., et al. Smoking and drinking among alcoholics in treatment: cross-sectional and longitudinal relationships. Journal of Studies on Alcohol (2000) 61:157–163.[Web of Science][Medline]
Jackson K. M., Sher K. J., Cooper M. L., et al. Adolescent alcohol and tobacco use: Onset, persistence and trajectories of use across two samples. Addiction (2002) 97:517–531.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Jackson K. M., Sher K. J., Wood P. K., et al. Alcohol and tobacco use disorders in a general population: Short-term and long-term associations from the St. Louis epidemiological catchment area study. Drug and Alcohol Dependence (2003) 71:239–253.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Jensen M. K., Sorensen T. I., Andersen A. T., et al. A prospective study of the association between smoking and later alcohol drinking in the general population. Addiction (2003) 98:355–363.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
John U., Meyer C., Rumpf H. J., et al. Strength of the relationship between tobacco smoking, nicotine dependence and the severity of alcohol dependence syndrome criteria in a population-based sample. Alcohol and Alcoholism (2003) 38:606–612.
Johnson K. A., Jennison K. M. The drinking-smoking syndrome and social context. International Journal of the Addictions (1992) 27:749–792.[Web of Science][Medline]
Kjaer S. K., Van Den Brule A. J., Bock J. E., et al. Human papillomavirus–the most significant risk determinant of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. International Journal of Cancer (1996) 65:601–606.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Kraft P., Rise J. The relationship between sensation seeking and smoking, Alcohol-consumption and sexual-behavior among Norwegian adolescents. Health Education Research (1994) 9:193–200.
Le A. D., Wang A., Harding S., et al. Nicotine increases alcohol self-administration and reinstates alcohol seeking in rats. Psychopharmacology (Berl) (2003) 168:216–221.[CrossRef][Medline]
McKee S. A., Falba T., OMalley S. S., et al. Smoking status as a clinical indicator for alcohol misuse in US adults. Archives on International Medicine (2007) 167:716–721.[CrossRef]
Myers M. G., Doran N. M., Brown S. A. Is cigarette smoking related to alcohol use during the 8 years following treatment for adolescent alcohol and other drug abuse. Alcohol and Alcoholism (2007) 42:226–233.
Patrick D. L., Cheadle A., Thompson D. C., et al. The validity of self-reported smoking: A review and meta-analysis. American Journal of Public Health (1994) 84:1086–1093.
Ritchey P. N., Reid G. S., Hasse L. A. The relative influence of smoking on drinking and drinking on smoking among high school students in a rural tobacco-growing county. Journal of Adolescent Health (2001) 29:386–394.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Room R. Smoking and drinking as complementary behaviours. Biomedicine and Pharmacotherapy (2004) 58:111–115.[CrossRef]
Rose J. E., Brauer L. H., Behm F. M., et al. Psychopharmacological interactions between nicotine and ethanol. Nicotine and Tobacco Resistance (2004) 6:133–144.[CrossRef]
Sher K. J., Gotham H. J., Erickson D. J., et al. A prospective, high-risk study of the relationship between tobacco dependence and alcohol use disorders. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research (1996) 20:485–492.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Simon T. R., Sussman S., Dent C. W., et al. Prospective correlates of exclusive or combined adolescent use of cigarettes and smokeless tobacco: A replication-extension. Addictive Behaviors (1995) 20:517–524.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
True W. R., Xian H., Scherrer J. F., et al. Common genetic vulnerability for nicotine and alcohol dependence in men. Archives of General Psychiatry (1999) 56:655–661.
Wetzels J. J., Kremers S. P., Vitoria P. D., et al. The alcohol-tobacco relationship: A prospective study among adolescents in six European countries. Addiction (2003) 98:1755–1763.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
![]()
CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us What's this?
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||